Hansard, October 28, 2015:Recommend this post
Yesterday I asked the Premier if she would apologize to Tim Duncan, the courageous whistle-blower who came forward when he was bullied by an official in the Minister of Transportation's office and directed to delete e-mails that he felt needed to be retained to respond to an access-to-information investigation. She refused to offer an explanation or an apology to Mr. Duncan.
We asked her why it was that the person responsible for freedom of information in her office used a tracking system consisting of Post-it Notes, and she didn't answer. We asked the Premier why she had said in May, and then again as recently as this fall, that she wouldn't tolerate anyone working in the government that wasn't abiding by the rules. Yet Ms. Cadario and Mr. Facey, identified by the commissioner, continue to be in the employ of the province of British Columbia.
My question again, given 24 hours, is to the Premier. Will she do the right thing, apologize to Mr. Duncan and also follow through on her commitment to ensure that people working under her are not breaking the law?
...Well, they said they wouldn't do it again in 2012. They said they wouldn't do it again in 2013. Now here we are, two years later, and we're still not going to do it again.
But it's not just Ms. Cadario who has an absence of records. It's not just the Premier who has an absence of records. We contacted, as I said yesterday and we raised here yesterday, the Premier's office and asked if Mr. Dyble, her deputy minister, had any records, any documentation around litigation, around internal investigations, around the botched firing of seven health care workers. Now, one would think, with all of the activity around that file, that someone in the Premier's office would have kept a scrap of paper, but that is not the case.
We then asked for another series of information from the Premier's communications director, Ben Chin. We asked if he had kept any records or documents over a period of time. You can well imagine the response we got... But the communications director, the guy responsible for making some sense of the incoherence in the Premier's office, did not keep one scrap of paper.
So my question, again, to the Premier is: if the Premier's director of communications doesn't write anything down — he doesn't send any e-mails — how is it that he communicates her inexplicable vision to the people of British Columbia?