Thursday, October 28, 2010

Not merely consistent with guilt but inconsistent with innocence.

Written in April 2010, this is one of the most popular reads on Northern Insights. I want to keep it at the top for a while longer because it deals with many issues that are in play right now.  Did Premier Campbell restore any faith by his October 27 speech? Not with anyone who has been paying attention.

During the Liberal years, Gordon Campbell remade British Columbia. While the provincial economy grew, the fortunes of ordinary people declined, for the first extended period ever. Beneficiaries of change had demanded redistribution of wealth to the disadvantage of all but a few. The end result was not incidental or accidental.

For success, the Liberals needed heroes and villains. That required a massive long-term campaign, involving information and disinformation. It was organized more easily than most citizens would expect and paid for by the public purse.

Media cooperated readily to carry messages. With ownership by sympathetic plutocrats, these dependable friends gained from government advertising campaigns. PAB brought together major elements of the information enterprise by centralization of government communications. With considerable funding, hundreds of servants loyal to the Premier shaped and filtered messages.

"Think tank" Fraser Institute, financed by large industry, particularly the energy and private medicine sectors, spends over a million dollars a month on its campaign against the public sector. Libertarians who aim to defund government, resource companies that abhor royalties and regulations, corporations lobbying for privatized healthcare and large tax resisters develop Fraser Institute philosophies.

Message making began even before the 2001 election. Creating villains was the first act. A few old guard political opponents, Stupich and Williams, come to mind as easy targets. Destroying Harcourt and Clark took longer because they were essentially good people, as lives after politics demonstrated. Clark, for example, flourished as a Jim Pattison Enterprises executive and people do not survive in that empire if they are dull or corrupt. That did not stop media from portraying him as a cheat because a friend helped him make home improvements.

RCMP even arranged for TV news cameras to be present for a search of Premier Clark's east Vancouver home. It may be significant that the officer in charge of the investigation once said, “Smear campaigns are our specialty” and Campbell had invited him to stand as a Liberal candidate with possibility of joining the Cabinet.

Media did not show the man that neighbors knew, the father of a young family who stood easily in a crowd of fellow parents watching their kids play minor hockey. Ultimately, a Supreme Court Judge tossed the politically motivated charges.

Labor unions were equally important targets. British Columbia prosperity had been based on its high wage economy. Communities, including Powell River where I did high school, lived happily, largely in middle class egalitarianism. We joked about "two boats in every driveway."

For decades, provincially controlled resource companies and unions survived with times of creative tension but the working classes were empowered, unlike the days when company towns exercised centralized control of jobs, housing, merchandising and every other life element. Workers could be summarily discharged and run out of town - and they were - for offending a manager or being suspected of socialist sympathy.

Education, healthcare, roads and ferry services, main enterprises of government, were targeted for intensive mistreatment. Part of the strategy was to attack the status of employees, accuse them of radicalism, inefficiency and greed. The object of government HR policy was not good labor-management relations; it was to create divides and disruptions. Old contracts were revoked, new ones imposed. Privatization was the aim, even if the contractors were disreputable dodgers headquartered in havens far removed from regulation and taxation.

Campbell's political operatives spread through the public sector, replacing professional managers with agents of the downtown Politburo. Our fine paramedic service has been, and is, subject to intensive disrespect to ready it for privatization. Lee Doney is there to ensure that happens according to plan.

Fast aluminum ferries were taken out of service to shame the NDP. Ships that could have been made serviceable were given away to Liberal supporters for less even than scrap value. After keeping them on public display in the Vancouver harbor, the company sold the ships for service to the UAE, for an undisclosed price with a gain known to be substantial. Of course, the public that paid to build these ships gets no disposal detail.

A long history of inexpensive clean power was targeted for elimination. Premier WAC Bennett said that low cost power would be the foundation for job development as long as the resource was used at home, not exported south to run factories of the USA. Gordon Campbell turned that policy on its head. Now, BC Hydro is obliged to purchase high cost interruptible power so they can dump it in the export market at a loss.

BC gains hugely now from low cost "heritage" generation sites. Without publicly owned projects, there will be no new ones because private facilities will demand "world prices" in subsequent contract terms. Imagine if private companies had built the Peace and Columbia River dams in the sixties. The utility would triple today's electricity prices.

Even worse, BC Hydro intends to allow private producers to sell their own non-firm-power as firm-power by lending from BC Hydro's predictable resource, when private supply runs low. So irregular power production will be topped up from public sources while the price premium stays in private hands. At times of high demand and high prices, BC Hydro power will be given to the privates to sell. When export demand and prices are low, BC Hydro will take back from the privates. We will be told it was merely a balanced commodity trade, one kwh traded for another kwh; balanced trade sounds so innocuous. This is planned fraud, shielded from public view by government imposed secrecy. The beneficiaries are common to other frauds.

Commuters in the working class suburbs of Pitt Meadows and Langley pay tolls to cross the Fraser River while luxury SUVs head for the ski slopes of Whistler on the $600 million untolled highway. By the way, if you want evidence that Canwest Global newspapers are message carriers for the Liberal government, examine this puffery in the Vancouver Sun. (Writer's note: Laila Yuile discovered that taxpayers are paying shadow tolls to to the Sea to Sky Highway private operator (S2S Transportation Group) for all vehicles driving the roadway.)

One attitude of citizens that Gordon Campbell's governance has reinforced beyond all reasonable levels is distrust. Distrust is the confident expectation that another individual's motives, intentions and behaviors are sinister and harmful to one's own interests. Regular readers know that I have written about how one hand cleans another when plutocrats do the washing up.

We have accumulated so much indirect and circumstantial evidence of corruption that, despite frenetic efforts of Liberal defenders, a reasonable person can draw only one conclusion. The facts are not merely consistent with guilt but inconsistent with innocence.
Recommend this post


  1. Norm, this is the most eloquent summary of what has been going on around these parts leading upto and since the coup d'etat against justice that has been perpetrated on the citizens of BC that I have run across in a long, long time, if not ever. I will be posting a post about this post over at the House, insisting, well strongly recommending, that folks come on over and read this in its entirity.

    thank you

  2. Thanks for that comment. The title conveys a message that we have to carry to others, everywhere. Campbell is merely a tool for this province; there are others like him in every jurisdiction. This is not a conspiracy; it is the outcome of the human instinct to act in self interest. The richest and powerful 1% can afford to buy tools to act on their behalf. The rest of us are left shouting into the wind, but we have numbers on our side.

  3. That's it in a nutshell,thanx Norm.GENUINE.

  4. Great analysis. As we watch how cozy we have become with highly subsid...err....incentived natural gas producers and wind farmers, who show no regard for BC jobs after they squeeze great deals out of the government, we need to take back control of at least who gets the jobs. The outflow of income taxes in the Northeast has never been higher and will be the death knell of many BC based businesses.

  5. The sad part is that ordinary citizens pay the cost of their own oppression. It is not Campbell and friends paying for PAB. Taxpayers pay for that propaganda arm.

  6. cfvua - You get it. Even in the midst of a budget breakdown, the Liberals decreased royalties and increased tax credits, allegedly to increase exploration activity. In fact the reductions were to make the already identified gas more profitable as it was produced.

    If you have been following the ProPublica series (many linked here at Northern Insights) on modern gas drilling and fracking, you know that citizens of the northeast will be left with something dangerous to life. When the gas has been sucked dry, grounds will be poisoned by unknown toxic chemicals, pumped into the ground under pressure to cause the release of natural gas.

    Despite new dangerous production methods, self-regulation is fine with Liberals. Don't the citizens of the northeast realize the dangers? Sure, short term jobs are nice but what happens to your children and grandchildren when the groundwater is toxic?

    I don't advocate or accept bombs hidden in the night as a way of protest. It is our words that should be explosive as we spread them around the province.

  7. Well done Norm - eloquently well written.

    I think the general public at large, are only just starting to realize the harm the the Campbell regime is doing to British Columbiia. Most people are too busy earning a living to pay too much attention to what is happening in the political circus the Victoria has become - so you writing is most desperately needed.

    It is indeed a sad time for British Columbia - which is saddled with a premier that is dishonest, a drunk (no evidence yet to the contrary), lacks integrity, cannot be trusted and, it seems, has little concern for what is in the best interests for british Columbia. This poor excuse for a man is interested in only what is good for Gordon Campbell and his party stooges and gives nary a thought ofr the province.

    It is interesting that this premier recently made a great effort to win over the First Nations people with cash settlements and new treaties, only later to be accused of trying to influence decisions on construction projects etc. Plans for Alberta Tar Sands oil to be shipped out of Prince Rupert, through a pipeline to be built on First Nations land, shipped in oil tankers using inland waterways - First Nation waterways. Now ROR projects that intrude into Coastal Protective Forest areas (Spirit Bear territory and world heritage site) and ruin wild salmon spawning grounds - where is the DFO and DOE ???

    Anything that can be done to hasten the demise of Herr Campbell will go a long way to helping British Columbia, to at least, try to recover from this corporate onslaught.

    Thanks for your writing - please keep doing it.


  8. Thanks all for the comments here. Remember though that blogs work a bit like chain letters. I can write opinions here where the weekly audience is a few thousands, in good weeks. Global TV News can ignore stories or present false reports about how wonderful private healthcare would be and their weekly cumulative audience is over a million

    The disinformation campaign is so loud that we can only compete if readers help share the messages. Send the links to blogs you rate well to everyone in your contact list. I don't mean this site in particular, link to anything that you believe your acquaintance should read.

    If those links are passed around in a chain, the words will be spread like water through a broken dam.

  9. Norman, we do spread the word. It is not always reflected in your numbers here, because alot of these subjects are discussed over morning coffee with people who don't have time to read.

  10. Kim, I particularly appreciate loyal readers like you who take time to add to the discussions. Thanks.

  11. Norman:

    I'm going to circulate this on a lively ListServ I belong to ... many thanks for wrapping the big topic up this way.

    Here's a thought. A commenter at my place provided advance notice of celebrations in Vancouver on Friday & Saturday -- April 23 & 24 -- of the 100th anniversary of British Columbia's Court of Appeal. Chief Justice Beverly McLaughlin is the keynote speaker. Lots of focus on The Law ... the Judiciary ... and if you ask me ... on whether Justice is Being Seen To Be Done in B.C. A few more details at my place.

    There's a call for sidewalk pickets with placards ... a tactic which always catches the attention of newsmen.

    God knows, we must do something that's visible ... positive ... and compelling enough to force Canada's judges to ask themselves if things are actually out of control in BC.

  12. Here's that announcement:

    To all who are interested in the BC judicial system.

    On April 23 and 24, 2010 in Vancouver, the legal establishment will gather to celebrate the:



    I suggest that as many of us who can, attend. And for others who may not be able to afford or be allowed, to attend, that they organize an "information session" outside with placards displaying key concerns regarding BC's justice system.

    The conference’s CENTENARY GALA DINNER will be held Friday, April 23, 2010 from 6 pm to 10 pm at The Westin Bayshore. It's sold out because the Keynote Speaker is Chief Justice of the Canadian Supreme Court, Beverley McLachlin. Chief Justice McLachlin may be very interested in the issues that concerned citizens have about BC's justice system. I envision "information placards" surrounding the transparent walls of The Bayshore. How illuminating it would be!

    Some of the topics in the regular conference include:
    * Effect of Disruptive Technologies and Social Developments on the Legal System
    * Evolving Challenges for Courts in Democracies
    * Confidence in the Justice System in British Columbia
    * Media and Public Perceptions of the Judiciary

    One of the conference speakers is Prof. Judith Resnick. If that's Judy Resnick, then we might see some interesting sparks fly!

    This might be one fine opportunity, and the timing couldn't be better.

  13. "Even worse, BC Hydro intends to allow private producers to sell their own non-firm-power as firm-power..."

    Norman, I don't quite get what you're saying in this paragraph.

    Can you clarify?


  14. Thank you Norman for this articulate and telling expose of Gordon Campbell's Machiavellian plot to seize government for the enrichment of a few plutocrat supporters. More people should have taken notice when Gordon Wilson exclaimed that the B.C. Liberal Party was being hijacked by a "pernicious cabal of malcontents."

    What Campbell fails to realise is that Machiavelli wrote "Il Principe" as a satire on tyrannical political leadership; anyone foolish enough to follow the directions in this political handbook would eventually face political disaster. (Let us hope Campbell's disaster arrives sooner rather than later). We can hardly afford even a few more years of financial mismanagement and political corruption by the renowned developer of the Georgian Court Hotel.

    As a matter of interest, Madame Justice Elizabeth Bennett was the B.C. Supreme Court judge who acquitted Premier Glen Clark in the ill-founded breach-of-trust case. Is it mere coincidence that the same Madame Justice Bennett was given an untimely promotion to the B.C. Court of Appeal just as the "BC Railgate"/Basi Virk caper was heading to trial? Talk about political manipulation of the judiciary. (This matter alone would provide days of discussions at the upcoming justice conference - messing with the independence of the judiciary, destroying potential evidence [government documents and e-mails related to the outrageous "999 year lease" of BC Rail to CN] etc.....).

  15. The message in the paragraph about firm and non-firm power may be garbled, but it's not a simple scheme.

    If private company X generates power by wind or river flow, the amount of electricity made is dependent on the wind blowing or the water flowing. Given uncertainty, the company cannot guarantee to a potential customer that its power is non-interruptible. That electricity therefore has lesser value to the customer who wants power whenever needed.

    If, instead, BC Hydro is required to lend any generation shortfall that private company X encounters due to adverse conditions, X will never lack for power. It could therefore commit uninterrupted electricity to its customer and, with that attribute, receive a much higher price in the sales contract.

    During particular seasons, the wind or river generated power will be in surplus (winter storms or spring melt) and Company X can deliver that excess to BC Hydro to replace the power borrowed previously.

    In the first stage of this scam, BC Hydro was being required to buy all private power produced at fixed high prices. BCH would be left to sell for whatever the market produced. Then the artists realized that they could earn more doing the trading themselves as long as they had a solution to shortages and an outlet for surplus power. For that reason, many experienced traders (10 as of February) left Powerex, BC Hydro's marketing subsidiary, and are establishing a new energy trading office in Vancouver for Morgan Stanley of New York.

  16. Thanks.

    But my understanding was that all IPP power is being sold only to BC Hydro. Which then hopes to export any surplus for a profit.

    I was not aware that IPPs were planning to export without going through BC Hydro, if that's what you are suggesting.

    Are you saying that IPPs in BC are planning to purchase BC Hydro firming capability, in order to make their power more profitable for export outside of BCH?

    It's interesting that BC Hydro is announcing additions to the Mica dam in the near future, partly to back up variable IPP power:


  17. Information sent me says this arrangement is in the works now but, of course, no public announcement has been made. In the long run, expecting private power generation to grow sufficiently, private export marketing is preferred by Campbell's people. This has been very profitable for BC Hydro over many years and those profits intrigue the new players. As Liberals are doing elsewhere, they prefer to privatize profit opportunities.

    The fact that Powerex already has lost numerous traders to the private sector is a confirmed factor that supports this scenario. The experienced traders earned handsomely with Powerex and you can bet they didn't jump from a comfortable spot into the midst of uncertainty.

    Liberals are being pressured to act because their backers see an end in site for this administration. However, they may need to moderate movement on remaining plans because of poor public support for the Liberals and a ticking clock to the next election.

    While the election is theoretically three years away, the politicians who are staying need time to prepare with Campbell no longer at the helm. That means there is only two years left of the current gravy train, less if backbenchers defect.

  18. Although the subject matter makes me sad, I'm glad you reposted this, Norman.

  19. I agree with Spartikus, thank you Norm.

  20. It saddens my heart to think of the devastation wrought upon this province by Gordon Campbell . Run-of-the-river projects, fish farms, sell off of BC Hydro and BC Rail. $6 million payout of legal bill for Basi/Virk yet cut backs in legal aid for the poor.
    BC has highest rate of child poverty in Canada - yet he boasts about lowering tax rate another by 15%. Meaningless drivel for the low-income wage earner; but a substantial increase for high-income earners (at the expense of all taxpayers - it's our money he's rebating).



This is an archive only of items published before April 22, 2016. These and newer articles are available at:

If you read an article at this blogger site, you can comment on it at the new site.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.